You are in: Home / Opinion / How the Rich Get Thin

How the Rich Get Thin

What is the association between rich people and thinness?

How the Rich Get Thin is a book from Park Avenue doctor Jana Klauer.

Apparently Dr. Klauer has a patient list including CEO's, celebrities, and other socialites at her expensive practice in New York.


In the book you get to see such ingredients as a "20 gram presentation of Caviar Tsar Imperial Beluga" (at $175 for a 50g serving). The actual diet emphasizes calcium and protein, and getting rid of processed foods. In an interview with Newsweek the author points out that the diet is not just about rich people.

...just because you're poor doesn't mean you have to be fat. You just have to make the right choices. I know it's easier to rely on convenience foods. But fresh vegetables aren't expensive. You can buy less-expensive cuts of meat and cook it longer with fresh herbs.
I don't agree. In my small part of the world, getting a variety of fresh vegetables can be a lot more expensive that getting a cheap loaf of white bread. Less-expensive meats tend to have a lot more "marbling" and saturated fat content.

I suspect the rich get thin because of liposuction, nips and tucks - and a one-on-one personal trainer... and of course their regular consultations with an expensive weight loss specialist on Park Avenue.

I'm not getting at so-called "rich" people - just the implication that by being rich you learn "extra" secrets about weight loss. As for the connection between dairy products and weight loss - the jury is out on that one. There are arguments both for and against the benefits of dairy foods for weight loss.

I wouldn't worry about what rich people do to get thin. Worry about what you can do to feel healthier and better about yourself.

Or even better - don't worry at all.

Read More

54 Comments

YD

Let's not forget personal chefs ala Oprah.

Reply
sevensmith


Why do so many people just jump to the fact that rich people can afford to cheat by using lipo?

What about the idea that these people are rich because they work hard and have high standards for their lives?

Reply
African Mango Lover

Being rich just gives you an advantage of having someone tell you what to eat and you paying the consultation fee. Poor people can get it for free just by being a little more eager to learn about it. Social media and the internet makes these details open to the public. ;)

Reply
Tincap

I agree whole heartedly with your comment regarding the fresh vegetables and white bread.

Normally USDA Prime is more marbled then USDA Select, when talking about beef. Select is the cheaper.

Reply
Christi Nielsen

I saw that book yesterday at the bookstore and almost laughed out loud. Of course it was after scanning an entire table stacked high with about 40 different diet books. I wish I had my camera.

The bit about vegetables not being that expensive is totally untrue. It's so much cheaper to buy bread, pasta, rice, and fast food than to stock the pantry and fridge with fresh whole foods.

Reply
Spectra

I'm pretty sure that the thin rich people are like that because of several reasons: 1)unlimited plastic surgery options 2)Personal trainers/home gyms that would put health clubs to shame 3)chefs that tell them exactly what to eat and when 4)certain designer drugs that are expensive to obtain 5)having more time than most people to devote to themselves thanks to lots of maids, nannies, etc.

Let's not forget that eating healthy and eating cheaply are not mutually exclusive. I buy in-season produce, fat free dairy products, and lean meats without ringing up a huge grocery bill. I don't buy a lot of name brand, processed, or junk foods.

Reply
L L Davis

I agree with the statement about white bread and vegatables, If good foods were lesser priced more people would be healthy. It is due to having to get rid of certain excess drugs and big businesses that things are priced as they are, I don't think it has to do with availabilities.

Reply
Robyn

Think about it, I have I millions of dollars, I no longer have to work nine to five. I can afford to live in a mansion on a multi-acre estate. I have access to my own personal swimming pool, weight room, gym, tennis court or outdoor recreation. I spend my time meeting and dealing with other wealthy people, traveling, shopping or laying about my giant home. Five o'clock rolls around, hmm, supper..I ring a bell or pick up a phone state four ingredients that sound appealling. I put down the phone and in lets say half an hour dinner is served. What lays on my plate? Kraft dinner? Don't be foolish. Spagetti? No I don't think so. I have a sous-chef, there is nothing but the latest in healthy, tasty and exotic food. I don't have a monthly food budget in which I have to feed four people. In fact I have no budget like that at all. I look for quality not quanity to fill my shelves. When I choose a restraunt I have not graced the door to a Macdonalds because with my wealth comes the more important factor of time. I have the time to sit and enjoy a meal without the worry of what more I have to get done in a twenty-four hour period after working all day. And goodness gracious if I do get a bit of pudge forming around my mid section I can either call in my private renowed instructor or a doctor. See follow these simple, easy steps and you to can lose the unwanted weight around your mid-section! Me I have to catch a nine thirty flight to Greece the beaches are calling!

Reply
phee

Get over yourself and stop bragging.

Reply
duh!

im pretty sure she was being sarcastic

Reply
Vern Kirkman

I'm thinking Liposuction, too, has more to do with their thinness than their diet.

I am supporting a family of six on 30 grand a year, with no other income. Caviar? I think not!

Reply
James

I personally don't think that the rich have an advantage over middle income people when it comes to choosing the food you eat. It is your choice whether or not to eat McDonalds or something you prepare. I think that the Dr. has a very good point of staying away from processed foods. Think about it. If you eat natural foods like seafood,rice naturally grown vegtables and wild meat(deer,moose ect) your going to have a much healthier diet.

Reply
Lana

i agree with Spectra. i'm poor, genuinely poor in fact. Things are getting better, but there have been times in the past where i had to choose between buying toothpaste and soap, because i wouldn't have enough cash for both for a few days. Canned fish, like tuna, salmon, sardines and herring are inexpensive and excellect diet choices. Low fat dairy is inexpensive, bags of frozen veggies are inexpensive, in season fruit is inexpensive, chicken is inexpensive, having lean red meat several times a week is not terribly expensive. Even though i can buy cheap white bread, i never would, even though it is inexpensive, because it lacks enough nutritional quality to justify its purchase. And nutritional/diet concerns aside, i don't even enjoy it over other foods, so why bother?

i eat alot of dried fruit, which is inexpensive and healthy. i buy a 1 lbs bag of cooking dates for $1 from the "baking needs" section of the supermarket, and have them with extra light cream cheese. Not only is that a cheap snack, but it is relatively low in calories compared to other options, and has nutritional benifits in the form of potassium, iron, B vitamins and calcium. You CAN find inexpensive, healthy food options, no matter how poor you are.

And if you "have" to go to a fast food place, since i keep hearing about how poor people can't afford not to at times, you can choose to get a 99cent, 200 calorie chili from Wendy's instead of an 800 calorie burger. Even fast food places now have healthy choices. And if you know that that McDonalds salad with the high calorie dressing has more calories then a burger, then leave the dressing off....

Reply
phee

I disagree. If you're dirt poor and starving, clearly you cannot afford ANY food.

Reply
Angela

If you're dirt poor and starving, then you don't have to worry about being fat, now do you?

Reply
Raquel

I totally agree with Lana. Fruits and vegetables are not expensive. For the cost of a quarter pound hamburger at McDonalds you can buy a lb. of ground beef and make 4 healther hambugers. For the price of one TV dinner, you can buy the same ingredients, which may cost more, but you can make 3 or 4 dinners with it. White bread does cost less, but there are cheap wheat breads also. And there are always coupons. You can also puchase apples, red peppers and potatoes by the bags instead of indiviually, which cost less per pound. I don't have much time to cook a dinner everynight. So when I get a free moment I prepare meals ahead and store them in the fridge for the week or the freezer for the month. I also involve my kids to help and my husband.
For snacks we have cheese and crackers, salsa and chips, pretzels, carrots, celery. All of which cost less than a bag of oreos, even the generic kind. I do buy the ocassional cookies, but the are allowed only once in awhile, which makes them last longer.

It is all about SMART shopping & SMART living. Not excuses.

Reply
Lana

Also, i often hear the macaroni & cheese excuse....that macaroni & cheese is inexpensive compared to other, healtheir alternatives...Yet i noticed a 10 serving bag of brown rice costs the same as a 4 serving sachet of macaroni & cheese....Even pasta like spagetti can be very healthy as long as a reasonable seriving size is used, and it isnt drenched in butter, or too much fatty minced beef...

Reply
Dhillon

What I find helps is neither expensive nor difficult, walking! I find that just walking 5 kilometres, 3 times a week, helps tremendously provided you do not overeat.

Drinking less coffee and more pepermint tea also helps.

Reply
edog

eating healthier alternative can be much mor expensive over the much more inexpensive processed foods. question if a chicken has 2 legs, 2 thighs, and two breast, why are chicken breast much more expensive just because it has less fat? the price should be the same because it's coming from the same chicken. whenever there is new information stating any health benefit watch the price go up. Natural foods are in there natural state, processed food go from natural to processed, why are they more expensive? the majority of this countrys weight problems has nothing to do with being rich or poor everything in country is based on fast and convienence. Look at any advertisment for these fast food there is always slim attractive people eating these products. Just the opposite of whom usually indulges these foods. If the goverment made a real effort to promote healthier eating habits, by reducing the price of healthier foods, and increasing the price of fast food that would be a major step in helping people maintain a healthier lifestyle, and weight

Reply
Inna

I read this book 'How the rich get thin' and decided to give it a try. I'm about 15-20 lbs from where I want to be.
I started this diet on about 2 weeks ago and I lost 5 lbs already. I don't really follow the plan 100% but I try.
What is very interesting about this diet that you don't get hungry, and you don't have craving for food. I need to lose more weight, so I'll see how it goes.
I'm not rich but I can buy the things she recommends.

Reply
Jocelyn

Buy you fresh vegetables from the FLEA MARKET, where they are about 1/3 of the cost that they are in grocery stores. Buy dried beans, soak them overnight, and eat them with brown rice. For vegetarians like me, that provides a complete protein. Cumin is great as a seasoning and relatively inexpensive considering how much you use and how much you save on your veggies. Cheap, Cheap, Cheap. Healthy. I was never overweight, but I have lost 5 lbs in 2 weeks by doing this alone and no other changes. It got rid of that extra little layer of fat all over me. All the extra fiber I've been getting stops food build up in my system. The lack of processed foods in my diet has helped decrease the toxins in my system. Nothing is impossible with the right know-how.

Reply


More comments: 1 2 3 4

Add Your Comment

Required
Required (never displayed)

Be nice. There's already enough mean people in the world.


Created / Updated: November 8, 2011

WHAT IS DIET BLOG?

We take the best of diet news and advice - and combine it with real-world application and opinion.

Find out who we are and don't hesitate to contact us, we'd love to hear from you.

"We're fatter than ever while popular media is saturated with skinny. How did it get to be so complicated?"

Privacy Policy | Sponsor Policy & Disclosure | Terms of Use | Medical Disclaimer ©2003-2011 Diet-Blog v2.0 - All Rights Reserved.