user-pic

A Low Carb Diet Cured My Hunger Pangs

Vote 1 Vote

I've been very hesitant the past decade about trying the low carb diet. It just sounded kinda gimmicky to me. But after a couple years of unsuccessful dieting (low calories...low fat) despite working out hard three times a week, I finally gave in and decided to give it a shot. The first week was agony - I had these intense visceral cravings for carbs and it seemed like 99% of the food out there was made from some form of refined grain or sugar. Two weeks into it and all of a sudden my cravings are gone. You could put a giant piece of chocolate cake in front of me, and I wouldn't even have a desire to eat it. This is the first time IN MY LIFE that i can remember not feeling hungry....at all, it's almost unreal. I think that maybe carbs were causing insulin highs and lows and that somehow made me really hungry all the time...but who knows. Was I carb intolerant? Do I have insulin resistance? Whatever it is, it's working...and I feel good and full of energy, and most amazingly not hungry despite eating half the calories I used to. Just wondering if there were people out there with similar experiences.

I also wanted to comment on society's perception of overweight individuals. So I have always felt this intense shame that I wasn't able to overcome my hunger pangs, I believed that it was a character flaw and that had I a stronger will and self control, that I'd be able to overcome my weight issues. In all other areas of my life I am extremely disciplined. I study and work 20 hours a day and I work out hard three times a week. I never miss a day of class, and have been working my butt off everyday for the past 10 years to get into the graduate program of my dreams. Does not being able to lose weight still make me a lazy slob?

While it's true that anyone that sticks to a strict calorie restriction regime will eventually lose weight, I don't think it necessarily leads to a higher quality of life. I know several people that have lost weight successfully through weight watchers that tell me they go to bed extremely hungry each night in order to stay thin, and they're miserable because of it. Hunger is a primal bodily drive, it's like going thirsty everyday forever or having to pee all the time for the rest of your life. I truly believe that when your mind tries to fight your body the body will always win in the long run. And yet, in our society, not eating in spite of extreme hunger is extolled as a virtue.

Moreover I believe that that the harshest critics are people that don't and never have had such intense hunger....or have never had to battle with a metabolic disorder.

Not being hungry for the first time in my life really got me thinking the past few days. Now that I'm not fighting an uphill battle with my body, it's easy for me to "choose" not to overindulge. I just do what my mind tells me to. Sure, I COULD stuff myself after a long workout...and it would be fun, but I'm able to tell me body no now much more easily. I'm down 8 pounds already...and very hopeful!

I just wanted people to keep in mind that there are much larger issues than a simple matter of self control when it comes to weight control. Telling a hungry person to "just not eat" because overeating is slobbish, disgusting and not rational does nothing but lower their sense of self worth.

Thanks for listening to my rant :)



5 Comments

  • I've been part of the Paleo/Primal eating sect for a few years now. You should know that anything that turns to sugar (carbs) is basically a drug. THe body needs protein and fat, but can make glucose therefore carbs are not essential. Keep on keeping on with eating low carb. One suggestion, there is a lot of evidence that eating higher fat, moderate protein and low carb is better than high protein. Our bodies can only use moderate amounts of protein at a time, so excess turns into sugar. Fats are totally inert, so will never spike insulin on their own.

    Reply
  • user-pic

    Congrats - you discovered what the rest of us have. Low carb just works.

    Reply
  • Eileen - Please read Good Calories Bad Calories by Gary Taubes - everything you discussed above is addressed in the book - satiety is a key factor in physical and mental well health. The book is a scientific analysis of dietary recommendations for the last 200 years - no recipes here. Good luck - also check out Jimmy Moore's blog on the web and the movie FatHead.

    Reply
  • Thanks for the tips and support everyone. I'll try eating more fat and watering the movie Fathead!

    Reply
  • user-pic

    From Jim Hart
    As a personal trainer and nutrition coach I have long suspected excess carbs as the culprit in the best laid diet and eating strategies. I too have struggled not only with my own cravings but have many clients who complain of the same problems despite following a healthy eating plan.
    The issus is complicated and differs with individuals but I have found going low carb ( no flour or sugar- abundant amounts of veggies and limited high fiber starches) is the way to maintain lower body fat and more energy.
    A good book recently published can give you some insight on this- THE METABOLISM MIRACLE and there is a great article on TIME.com called the science of appetite. I am happy you have found what works for you and I wish you continued success.
    JIM HART fiftyplusfitness

    Reply

Add Your Comment

Required
Required (never displayed)
Comments may be held for moderation.

NEXT POST: Is BMI a Good Reference to Go By? »
Start Sharing!
Ask a question, tell your story, share advice. The best are featured on our home page
Submit New Post

New

Categories

About