Your Opinion Needed: Too Fat? Too Thin? Too Muscular? (Bro Version)

kevin james-too fat, jake gylenhaal-too muscular, george clooney-perfect, leonardo dicaprio-perfect, marc anthony-too thin, russel crowe-a little bit too fat- skip lacour- too muscular, phillip seymour hoffman-too fat, vince vaughn-a little bit too fat,

the best body has leonardo dicaprio and george clooney. they are not too thin and not too fat and not too muscular. i hate too muscular men.

Kevin James-too fat
Jake glyenhall- looking great either way
George Clooney- Average, not too bad, a little soft though
John Cena- too large for me
leonardo dicaprio- too soft
marc anthony- too skinny
Russell Crowe- too chubby, hard to tell with the picture shown for sure.
Skip lacour- He's in shape thats for sure, maybe a little large
Phillip Seymour-too heavy
Vince Vaughn- good before, too heavy now.

Best in there is Jake Gyllenhaal (muscular) but beyond that none really jump out at me as being bad just different.

In case it's not obvious, I'm a female...

Skip and John Cena are too muscular for me - it's intimidating. Marc Anthony is definitely too skinny.

Philip Seymour Hoffman is too heavy and Kevin James is a bit too. But I'm more likely to overlook heaviness (to a point) if the guy has a great personality.

Vince Vaughn swinger-days or George Clooney would probably be my ideal, as far as physique is concerned. All the rest I'm ambivalent about.

There are few overweight guys in there but not obese.

Jake (thin), Leonardo & Marc are too thin to me.

Jake, muscular is pretty good.

John & Skip look good as I like muscle but for me, I prefer a bit less.

Saying all that, I don't choose a guy based on this though.

I tend to find leaner/slimmer guys more appealing in general--probably because I'm a woman who bulks pretty easily--but more than anything, I like what looks healthy and natural on the person's frame.

Kevin James - too fat
Jake Gylenhaal (bulky) - too muscular/bulky
Jake Gylenhaal (thinner) - fine. Maybe a touch more body fat would be good.
George Clooney - fine. Could tone up a bit.
John Cena (WWE wrestler) - too muscular/bulky
Leonardo DiCaprio - fine. Could tone up a bit.
Marc Anthony - way too skinny! He looks unhealthy.
Russell Crowe - He looks overweight, but could just be an unflattering pose.
Skip Lacour - too muscular/bulky
Phillip Seymour Hoffman - too fat
Vince Vaughn (Swingers Days) - fine. Probably an ideal for me.
Vince Vaughn (nowadays) - too fat

I just like "normal". Di Caprio is fine. Vince Vaugh is fine either way. A bit chubby is fine for as long as he is healthy.

Kevin James- Fat.
Jake Gylenhaal- He looks better when he's leaner, but I wouldn't mind either ways - hot.
George Clooney- Normal, average.
John Cena- Muscular, but not overly so. Shows how much he cares about his looks and physique. Hot.
Leonardo DiCaprio- Average.
Marc Anthony- Average, skinny but not too skinny.
Russell Crowe- Yucks, unhealthy.
Skip lacour- Too muscular.
Phillip Seymour - Overweight.
Vince Vaughn- Looks awesome before, fat now.

That's my opinion... I think men look better when they're toned and a little more muscular than when they are 'soft' and pudgy.

I'm a female, so you can take that into account:

Kevin James- A little bit too fat for my tastes
Jake Gylenhaal- Looks good both ways, but seems more muscular in the first pic. I prefer the thinner version.
George Clooney- Pretty average; good for an old guy.
John Cena- Muscular with big arms...I have a weakness for guys with huge guns, so I think he's pretty hot.
Leonardo DiCaprio- Average.
Marc Anthony- Kind of on the skinny side, but not bad.
Russell Crowe- Fat in a gross, drinks-too-much-beer kinda way.
Skip lacour- Muscular, but he looks really good. Not overly veiny or weird.
Phillip Seymour - Too much of a belly.
Vince Vaughn- Used to be average/muscular, now he's pretty pasty and mushy-looking.

I prefer guys to be bigger; skinny guys are a turnoff for me, but I like guys that aren't just "fat", but "husky"...I'd prefer someone with Kevin James' physique to someone like Philip Seymour Hoffmann.

Kevin James- fat
Jake Gylenhaal- I like the muscular pic better
George Clooney- flabby
John Cena- I likey
Leonardo DiCaprio- flabby
Marc Anthony- scrawny
Russell Crowe- fat
Skip lacour- nice
Phillip Seymour - slightly fat
Vince Vaughn- flabby

Clearly I go for the muscular look.

Kevin James-too fat
Jake glyenhall- looks great
George Clooney- He is ok
John Cena- To big
leonardo dicaprio- Not a fan at all he is ok
marc anthony- too skinny
Russell Crowe- too chubby
Skip lacour- to bulky
Phillip Seymour-too fat
Vince Vaughn- Heavy

I'd bet anything that Skip is no natural, or at least didn't build that foundation without drugs. Nobody gets that big while also staying that lean without chemical assistance.