How-To Guide: Workout Nutrition

There are messages a-plenty when it comes to optimizing peri-workout nutrition with supplement companies, sports nutrition authorities and body building forums all offering opinions. The result is a lot of confusion. My aim is to try and deliver a back-to-basics approach to pre, during and post workout nutrition.
To alleviate too much confusion, we will apply the following principles to sub-elite exercisers whose goals are health and fat-loss related.
- When training to drop body fat, total calories for the day matters most, with timing and types of foods being of secondary importance.
- Pinpoint precision is not necessary for the vast majority of exercisers as there is an overlap in meals throughout the day.
- The purpose of the pre-workout nutrition is to increase exercise performance, enhance muscle-building and saving and to boost muscle and liver glycogen stores.
- Tolerances vary in terms of how much and the type of food is consumed. Some people can tolerate a fairly big meal within an hour of exercise while some need a near-empty stomach.
- Aim to consume a protein + carbohydrate meal within 90 minutes of working out. An amount of .25g per pound of target weight for both carbohydrate and protein should suffice. Use fat as tolerated.
- In terms of carbohydrate type, a mix of high and low glycemic index carbs works fine for most people. Solid or liquid forms are just fine.
- Focus on maintaining hydration - aim for about 1L of water per hour of exercise the pre-exercise carbohydrate meal should take care of the rest.
- If your activity is less than 2 hours long, there is no need to ingest carbohydrate and or protein during activity.
- The purpose of post-exercise calorie intake isn't unlike that of pre-workout meal goals. After exercise, there is an optimal window whereby insulin sensitivity is heightened.
- Get your post-workout meal into your body as soon as possible (try within 30 min of training).
- Post exercise meal can be liquid or solid and should be about .25g per pound of target weight of protein and about .5g per pound of target body weight for carbs.
- Regarding essential amino acids, branch-chained amino acids and glutamine - no need to fret as most whey protein blends carry enough of these compounds to satisfy most people's goals.
What the above boils down to getting a carb+protein mix on either side of your exercise sessions. For most people this is sufficient in terms of optimal glycogen uptake, protein synthesis and averting protein breakdown.
What are your strategies for pre, during and post workout nutrition?
References:
Alan Aragon Research Review. Nutrient Timing parts 1,2,3.
Kleiner, Susan M. Power Eating. 2006
This is a great post. I actually do a lot of what you suggest.
alexis scott
ReplyI don't like to eat before I exercise as I have to run to the bathroom in the middle of my routine... Would a simple protein shake after a work out with fruit and milk be sufficient?
Reply"After exercise, there is an optimal window whereby insulin sensitivity is heightened. "
So, is it a good thing then, for someone who IS insulin resistant to eat during this time, or to just eat as normal (looking to loose weight here). I do tend to eat about 30 minutes after a workout, but it's my normal lunch.
ReplyI am an insulin resistant Type 2 diabetic.
To eat simply because someone tells you there is an "optimal window" (I've seen this referred to as an "anabolic window", as well) makes no sense. How about eating when you are hungry and not eating when you aren't instead?
Food supplement companies love this kind of nonsense. It sells more supplements. You don't need to eat within the mystical post-workout window if you are not hungry.
Protein supplements are unnecessary and again don't make sense for anybody trying to lose fat because they make for calorie-rich drinks. Why would anyone who is trying to eat less want to drink their food?
The notion of pre-, during-, and post-workout nutrition is a marketing device to sell supplements.
I lost over 130lb of fat without any of this nonsense and while using injected insulin which makes the process more challenging. I got stronger, and I didn't buy one isotonic, anabolic, whey-packed, wallet-emptying supplement to do it.
Craig
ReplyCraig, there's a book, quite well known in fact, called Nutrient Timing that covers the science behind the well proven fact that there is a post-workout window in which drinking a carbohydrate/protein based drink will be more anabolic. Calling it nonsense without a shred of evidence makes you look silly.
ReplyI just did the math and it turns out I was already doing this. Nice to see my "instincts" (actually info I distilled from a million sources) confirmed though.
Replyif your goal is fat loss, significant and thorough pre-w/o nutrition is useless or even counterproductive and wouldn't make any sense unless one feels real (physical) hunger...
post-w/o "window" is the best time to consume the largest amount of carbs in a day due to heightened insulin sensitivity...
personally, i do cardio on emty stomach in the morning and strength after eating 1 apple (or other fruit) an hour before a w/o, and try not to eat much carbs unless it is post-w/o...
ReplyWrong again. You shouldn't be exercising to burn calories. Create a caloric deficit with your diet and use the workout to preserve muscle. If you've created the deficit in your meal plan then pre/post workout nutrition will work fine and is a good idea.
ReplyComments are useless w/o references.
Everyone has their own exercise routine and diet. In my opinion, anyone looking to exercise should do whatever feels right. If you feel that a supplement would aid in your exercise routine or help you pass your plateau; it is your money to spend as well as your motivation.
For those people that do not believe in the efficacy of pre-workout a supplements:
JR Hoffman, J Kang et al. "Examination of a pre-exercise, high energy supplement on exercise performance" J Int Soc Sp Nutr 2009
Too lazy to summarize, just going to copy paste, "Results indicate a significant increase in reaction performance, with no effect on anaerobic power performance. In addition, ingestion of this supplement significantly improves subjective feelings of focus and energy in male strength/power athletes."
ReplyDo whatever feels right? Seriously? If anybody takes your advice they deserve all the failure they get.
Do not do what feels right. Do what is proven to work. It isn't as if there aren't thousands of studies showing exactly what causes lipolysis and what causes anabolism.
ReplyThis is a good post. One of the few on Diet Blog. It's sad that most people who exercise regularly don't know any of this stuff.
Reply