Too Fat for Clubbing?

bar.jpgAs someone who's been "shown the door" at nightclubs before, this article really annoyed me. A club in Australia faces hot water for barring heavy set women, but admitting men of similar size.

Yeah, because we all know how appealing fat dudes are! The bar's actions prompted protests and 1,000 people to join an internet-based campaign demanding a boycott of the nightclub.

Georgina Mason, 23, one of the barred women, said this to the Jersey Evening Post:

"I told them not to be ridiculous and asked to speak to the manager. When the manager came out he would not look at me directly but said they had received many complaints about fat people and he told me, 'Go and lose some weight before you can come in - fat people are bad for business."

Regardless of size, sex, color or creed, a paying customer is a paying customer and given the INSANE price of drinks nowadays, this joint should be happy SOMEONE wants to come in.

More like this in Body Image and Media Watch · Aug 18, 2008

31 Comments

Mark on 08/18/08

What a awful thing to do mind you there is fatism in the word some people are unbelievable mind you there loss.

Reply
Lauren on 08/18/08

This night club should be boycotted by its customers.
Today they don't let fat girls to get in, tomorrow they will decide that red heads aren't spending enough money on drinks.

Reply
jkd on 08/18/08

This isn't exactly news--clubs have always discriminated on appearance (weight, age, clothes, "beauty", social status, etc.). Personally, I don't get why anyone, regardless of appearance, would want to stand in line and pay an outrageous cover charge for the privilege of buying overpriced drinks and attempting to scream conversations to your friends over crummy techno music. Let them have their pretty-only policy.

Reply
Laura on 08/18/08

I too am not very surprised at this. Most clubs will look you up and down and decide if they want to let you in. You might be too fat, not wearing enough makeup, or not wearing a short enough skirt, but people always get denied. As much as it sucks when all your friends get in and you don't (believe me, I've been there), eventually it happens to everyone - you just have to laugh it off and go somewhere else. It's their right to decide who they want in and who they want out.

Reply
staci on 08/18/08

that's just as bad as being denied a flight for being too heavy. its rediculous and embarrassing. i just can't believe its because people complained about fat girls. its because woman are not discriminant. if we were, then there would be no one but women at bars, according to this story.

Reply
Jessie on 08/18/08

Maybe they were a fire hazard? :p

Reply
Trent on 08/18/08

I have no problem with this. If you want to talk about unfair, we can also discuss why men often pay cover charges and women don't.

The best solution is to just avoid going to these ridiculous places altogether. Go to a good bar instead where you can actually have a conversation.

Reply
Gerry Pugliese on 08/18/08

Hey Trent-

I agree with you on the men paying cover charges--drives me insane!

Peace.
-Gerry

Reply
Kailash on 08/18/08

It's one club. Go to another. If you can't get into any of them, start your own.

Simple as that.

Reply
Claire P. on 08/18/08

This isn't news to me either. As someone else said, clubs will discriminate based on if you're "too old," not pretty enough, not thin enough, whatever.
I'd rather go to a bar and skip the whole club scene altogether. So unappealing to me.

Reply
NeoVitin on 08/18/08

This seems like a terrible thing to do. If I owned a business I can't imagine excluding people from entering like this.

Reply
Jade on 08/18/08

I can understand why the manager had such a policy - good business must not be the only reason, I believe. I wonder why those protested for.

Yes, it's unfair. But we all know that life is not fair - so get used to it. (as said by Bill Gates recently on his speech at a High School about 11 things they did not and will not learn in school. It's the first rule he mentioned-Life is not fair-get used to it! And the second is The world won't care about your self-esteem.

The barred women should have gone back to high school dan listened to Gate's speech. :)

Reply
Fatno on 08/19/08

Urban legend. Bill Gates never gave any such speech.

Reply
Jade on 08/20/08

To my curiousity, who then used his fame and passed in the speech? The 11 rules in his speech were discussed in one best private high school in the city of my country. (I got it from a friend whose kid study in the high school) Shame on the school??? (of course, if you're right)

Reply
Jade on 08/20/08

Thanks a lot, Fatno, for informing me such a great website. I have never been there before. Will be visiting there often.. I wonder if it's just a coincidence you know this issue while in another part of the world there happened such false information told by an institution over a thousand high school students.

Reply
Meg on 08/18/08

That is really sad! Like others, however, if you look at the business side...not to be sexist, but guys often seem to value the looks of women over actually getting to know them. Well, I don't mean ALL guys, but definitely the types that frequent nightclubs. They want these seedy guys to come one, come all to spend, and one way to get that is sex appeal.

This is why the bar/club scene is a totally incompletely way of meeting new people. It's not about forming new relationships, it's about sex.

Reply
nodietneeded on 08/18/08

I am having a hard time to compare this with not accepting people based on the outfit. There more cases where you have to dress to the occassion. For those who are married, would you like to see your maid of honor or best men in flip flops ?

Also, the fact that men at the same weight are being accepted don't mean much to me either because if they weren't, that would have been equally wrong and couldn't justify this action.

As a last note; I think these kind of desicions are driven by the demand rather then evil spirited business owners. Why would a club executive not want heavy set women in her club? Most likely because she assumes that their presence will make the club scene less attractive for other prospect guests. Hmm, I wonder where she gets that idea? Of course they have a responsibility to make a desicion that doesn't violate any rights, but, to me, the underlying issue is that the demand (from the clubbers) is in support of such an action. Thank God there are still sensible people that protest this.

Reply
Yongho Shin on 08/18/08

"Bad for business"? Fat people order just as much drinks as other people. (Actually, probably more.)

What a horrible policy. Even if people don't boycott that club, they'll slowly lose customers.

Reply
lynn on 08/18/08

heck. i guess this bar doesnt sell overpriced food along with the overpriced drinks or fat people would be welcome.

Reply
Lila on 08/18/08

Ugh.. that makes me cringe.

Reply
Gabrielle on 08/18/08

Why is an Australian woman talking to the Jersey Evening Post about a low key domestic issue? Has this really been reported properly?

Reply
Alex Costa - minimizeme.tv on 08/18/08

The reason that fat men are aloud to enter is because they usually consume a lot and that means $$$$$

Reply
bijou on 08/18/08

it sucks. it's wrong. but it happens, and will continue happening. the fact that people, especially women, are judged at least partially based on our appearance is a harsh fact of life. unfortunately, gaining entrance into a club is not a right, and the owners have every right to select their patrons based on any criteria, no matter how arbitrary or repugnant they might seem. the heavy patrons can either lose weight or booze somewhere else.

Reply
scott on 08/18/08

It really isn't unfair because club admission is well-known to be all about appearances and social status. I am a thin male (due to adherence to a low-cal vegetarian diet) and am quite certain I am too ugly and plain to get into any high-status club.
As far as boycotting them, it will backfire. They are rightfully concerned that if they get a rep as a fatchick's club, their rankings will drop amongst the hip and beautiful society and the bigspending males that accompany them. A boycott will just draw attention to the club and give them positive endorsement from the people they want to attract.

Reply
Calidigital on 08/19/08

Thats kind of foul but turn it into a positive. Use the terrible incident as motivation to loose some weight and look a little sexier. **I'm not defending the discriminatory practice** I would just like to see people take responsibility for themselves so they don't continue to be in these types of situations.

Reply
Anoyn on 08/19/08

Good! About time someone stopping letting the fat and ugly in!

Reply
Karen on 08/21/08

And the most ironic thing of all is the owner himself is overweight!

Sorry, but the whole thing is a complete joke.

Reply
Spectra on 08/23/08

Around where I live, there aren't many nightclubs. Mostly, people just go to bars to drink. Or they go to the strip joints and drink. I will say that if they ever discriminated against fat people, they would have no business. Seriously, whenever I go to bars, I am probably one of the only non-college-aged woman there that is a normal weight. Most of the other women are stuffed into too-tight jeans and are wearing too-tight tops and are just spilling out everywhere. I don't get how discriminating against fat customers would be bad for business...like other posters said, fat people buy just as many drinks as anyone else. Maybe they won't go home with as hot of a guy/girl as a thinner/more in-shape person, but how is that any of the club's business?

Reply
Dr. Robyn Silverman on 09/06/08

It's amazing that we tell children never to judge a book by it's cover and yet, adults do it constantly.

I just wrote about this incredibly rude thing that happened to my friend when she was out at a bar last night-- I thought you'd appreciate it-- you won't believe it (or maybe you would!) Would love your thoughts.

http://kissmyassets.wordpress.com/2008/09/06/rudest-thing-said-about-your-body-body-image-slams-by-girls/

Anyway, I guess that's why we need to keep writing about this stuff and talking about this stuff. You just can't make this stuff up, can you?

Dr. Robyn

Reply
Redd on 10/03/08

I think that it's good to exclude overweight women from nightclubs. There is nothing that ruins a good time out like a fat woman who bugs you all night and won't take no for an answer. I've had this happen quite a few times and it's very annoying.

Reply

Add Your Comment

Required (nicknames or firstnames only)
Required (never displayed)
Optional



Most comments displayed immediately - some are held for moderation. (How to get an avatar)

©2003-2008 Diet-Blog - All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer