High Protein Pasta

by J. Foster

zonepasta.jpg

The Zone Diet is a well-known and respected diet from Dr Sears. However the commercial diet and website does seem to be quite focused on making products.

One particular product may be of interest - Zone pasta. The pasta was made to conform to Zone diet standards - and has a much higher amount of protein than normal pasta.

According to the USDA nutrient database - a 60g serving (dry) of pasta has around 5.5 grams of protein.

The Zone pasta has a massive 22 grams of protein.

Here is what the pasta is made from:

Durum wheat semolina, pea protein isolate, soy protein, high amylose maize starch, and egg white.

Most pasta is made just from wheat flour (and water).

As far as I'm aware this is the only high-protein pasta around. Weight for weight - it is much lower in carbohydrate than typical pasta. The big question has to be: What does it taste like? Anyone tried it?

Disclosure: This is not a paid ad or endorsement for a commercial product - but is chosen purely out of interest.

More like this in Food · Apr 21, 2008

19 Comments

Heather on 04/21/08

I haven't tried it. I normally use the Barilla Plus pasta if I make any.

Reply
Deirdre on 04/22/08

We (me, my husband, and my children) also eat Barilla Plus. It's "only" 10 grams of protein per serving. We like the taste and texture better than most white and whole wheat pastas. I'm not specifically looking for high protein, but I can't complain, either.

The ingredients in Barilla Plus are semolina, grain and legume flour blend (lentils, chick peas, oats, spelt, barley, egg whites, ground flaxseeds and wheat fiber), niacin, ferrous lactate (iron), thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid -- pretty good IMO.

The ingredients in the Zone pasta look a little questionable to me, and that does seem like an extreme amount of protein.

Reply
Panu on 04/21/08

Here in Finland one of our local pasta makers has Protein Pasta which has 23g of protein per 100g of dry pasta. And 6 grams of fiber.

Page is in finnish, but should give some more info:
http://www.torinopasta.fi/tuot_tummaproteiiniplus.htm

It is made from Dark durum wheat flour, wheat glutein, wheat germ, oat fiber, salt and water.

Reply
Panu on 04/21/08

Oh, and comment in taste. It tastes about same in my opinion than whole grain or similar pasta.

Reply
Red on 04/21/08

they should make a pasta out of meat. it would probably look similar to ground beef.

Reply
soozeequeue on 04/22/08

I agree. It's not any sillier than continuing to monkey with everything artificially. Do we have to keep putting one kind of nutrient into something that is basically a whole different thing altogether? What's wrong with a high fibre source of pasta with lean meat???? Pasta has some protein as it is. If I want to eat additional protein I will eat my pasta with some good organic cheese, beans, meat, or eggs.

Reply
Mike OD - IF Life on 04/21/08

60g/2oz is the serving size? I would be eating my hand and left ear after that....although maybe I would add another chicken breast to it to make it more filling as well. Like anything...portion control with something like that is what the inherent negative aspect can be. As most people may just cook the whole package and eat it.

Reply
Jan74 on 04/21/08

60g or 50g works if you add vegetables to it - pasta primavera, or Asian stir-fry type dishes like yakisoba, or make it as a side for a chicken breast. Then again, if you make it as a side for a chicken breast or something like that, you don't need protein pasta, do you?

100g is the serving size when you eat just a plate of pasta, but that is around 57g carb when cooked, for regular pasta. Not a big deal if you are gonna work out, but I wouldn't eat it more than occasionally anyway.

As for this pasta, if it had no soy, I'd buy it.

Reply
Spectra on 04/21/08

I usually just get the whole wheat pasta, but I might try this if I find it in the store soon. I'm impressed with how much protein is in it. And like Jan said, I'd probably make it with lots of veggies to fill out the portion size a bit.

Reply
FatLossBS on 04/21/08

wow, thats too much protein for me... I dunno if my kidneys would forgive me

Reply
ayse76 on 04/22/08

Or...you could just get regular WW pasta and top it with lean meat--which would provide your body with a much more useable form of protein than soy. What is with soy protein anyway? I know that soy has its purpose, and it's got its benefits, but sheesh--it's in everything!

Reply
Jan74 on 04/22/08

Buckwheat pasta is also good for you. Lower glycemic load and all that. I tend to buy whole-wheat durum and buckwheat. And occasionally rice noodles cause they are delicious.

I'm not against soy for people not on thyroid medication, but I still think more "normal" forms of soy, such as tofu and edamame, are preferable to isolated soy protein. Isolated soy protein is to soy like maize is to corn kernels, you know.

Reply
Glucomannan on 04/22/08

The western diet has too much protien as it is. Now linked to high blood pressure.

Reply
Jan74 on 04/23/08

The Western diet typically has 40% of calories from fat, 50% from carb, and 10% from protein. So it is low in protein, not high in protein, since no health authority recommends less than 20% of calories from protein.

Reply
Dr. J on 04/23/08

It seems to me that the average American eats a high protein diet. Not necessarily as a percentage, but in grams of protein per day. Actually, their diet is too high in everything, especially processed carbs :-)

Reply
Jan74 on 04/23/08

If you consider the "average" to be a fast-food for lunch, muffin or pop tart for breakfast, frozen food for dinner, chips for snacks person, I doubt they are eating too much protein. I mean, protein grams are based on body size, right? It is a minimum 60g for a woman, 70g for a man I believe of normal size, and it wouldn't be too much, even for a woman of normal size and following the traditional "protein will kill you and give you kidney disease" creed, until it got to 100g, if I recall correctly. So someone who is 50lb overweight, like the average person is, and eating that diet, he/she is eating:

31g protein in the big mac meal
5g protein in the pop tart
6g protein in an average pack of potato chips (nobody eats 1 serving.. 3 servings)
30g on a frozen dinner (I used the info for meatloaf with potato, and for steak with potato)
Let's throw in a doughnut eaten at the office - 4g
and also, a giant Starbucks coffee drink, with full fat milk - 13g

It is 89g. For a fat person. Hardly "too much protein".

Add a million calories in regular soda during the day, but no protein, and I think you'd have your average American there.

Reply
Spectra on 04/23/08

I think it depends on what you eat...my inlaws definitely don't lack in protein in their diets. Eggs, bacon, and toast for breakfast, chicken and a salad with baked potato and cottage cheese for lunch, beef of some sort with potatoes and some sort of cooked vegetable for dinner and milk with every meal. But yeah, I think most American diets are probably too high in everything, especially carbs.

Reply
Carol on 06/19/08

Re: Zone Pasta ..... I love it !!
I have tried many different healthy, protein pasta and by far the Zone pasta tastes great, cooks up better then most pasta .... I have to give it a 10.

The only thing is that when you order from the Zone site the shipping is almost as much as the boxes of pasta !!

Reply
Ed on 09/16/08

what's the point of fiddling around with enhanced pasta when there are better protein sources available?

Reply

Add Your Comment

Required (nicknames or firstnames only)
Required (never displayed)
Optional



Most comments displayed immediately - some are held for moderation. (How to get an avatar)

©2003-2008 Diet-Blog - All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer