You are in: Home / Meals / Diet Delivery: Rating the Plans

Diet Delivery: Rating the Plans

dietdelivery.gif

Epicurious have compared five popular delivered (prepared) diets. Fresh and whole foods win the ratings.

Rankings (from best to worst)

  1. Deliciously Yours (formerly eDiets Express) - Daily cost: $39.26
  2. Zone Chefs - Daily cost: $52.13
  3. Pure Foods Low Carb (formerly Atkins at Home) - Daily cost: $47.80
  4. Jenny Craig - Daily cost: $23.99
  5. Nutrisystem - Daily cost: $12.23

In many ways you get what you pay for - although $52 a day for the Zone meals is very expensive.

Home delivered diets are experiencing a surge in popularity - but I wonder how sustainable it is over the long term.

See the very comprehensive review over at Epicurious.

See also our huge list of diet delivery providers.

Read More

41 Comments

TheMorbidMe

The idea might be good, but by the end of the day, there will be nobody who will be watching you when you open the fridge to get that extra food. Dieting is in your brain.

Reply
Lose Weight With Me

I agree with TheMorbidMe's post. I can see where this would be very convenient, but it really doesn't address a lot of the behavior issues that cause us to be overweight, it doesn't educate, nor does it address exercise. I believe that until those things are addressed, chances are good that any weight lost will be temporary.

Brian

Reply
Lose Weight Guru

Brian hit the nail on the head. Losing weight is a lifestyle change, and people need to learn about foods, what's in them, what to prepare and how to prepare it in a healthy way. Besides that, I think they're all waaay to pricey.

Reply
mw

I'm on ZoneChefs and have lost 29 lbs since starting on 1/21 (I also exercise daily). As I live alone, I took care of the open refrigerator by getting rid of all perishables and all open or "bad" perishables. The first month I didn't cheat at all and ZC enabled me to get used to the portion sizes, made me try foods I wouldn't have, etc. Since then, I've had a few dips into the jasmine rice I couldn't bring myself to toss, but MUCH MUCH smaller portions than pre-diet that still felt like huge cheats. I also do a bit of substituting meal bars when I really hate a meal. The fact that the whole rating thing seems to be ignored by ZC makes me think EDiets might be worth a try as I wean myself from ZC over the next couple of months (recently dropped weekends).

But, I don't cook. It is expensive, but it has taught me lessons about food and eating that I don't think I could/would have done on my own. It's also a lot healthier than other pre-packaged meals (whether part of a service or in the grocer's freezer).

I think that if you can afford it and need to learn portion size, it can be a great choice, if only for a month to get used to smaller portions.

Reply
Victoria

"MW,"

What kind of exercise regimen do you have? You said that you work out daily, but just what do you do? And what is your body type and age? I'm 19, trying to lose about 25 pounds, and I want to try Nutrisystem, but I have no idea what exercise would be best paired with that system! Help??

Greatly appreciated!!!

VM

Reply
Rebekah

Just because prepared diets don't address all sides of the "weight issue" doesn't mean that they have no value. One of the largest problems those that wish to lose weight face when embarking on a diet is appropriate portion sizes, and prepared foods can really help a person "retrain" their mind in this area.

Weight loss can be a very daunting task--especially if one has tried and failed in the past. Pre-prepared foods can help simplify things and make the goal seem more reachable in the beginning.

Reply
Joc

Does anyone know the difference or have an opinion on the different zone delivery options? In the Zone versus Zone Chefs?

Reply
alicia

I am a young, active, medical student. Ironically, late-nights at the hospital and always eating "on the go" are my biggest downfalls. I think the pre-proportioned and nutritionally balanced meals are a wonderful idea for anyone who has a crazy schedule and finds themselves going through the drive-through (or vending machine!) instead of having a "real" meal. My husband and I are going to start Nutrisystem soon. We each have about 15lbs to lose; its more about having healthier meals available and getting "good" calories instead of the "empty" ones. And as far as the price goes - at about $25 a day for two people, that's MUCH less than we spend on eating out every night, junk food, food "to-go," etc.

Does anyone have any thoughts about the TASTE of the food in any of the pre-packed meals?

Reply
Rhonda

Alicia,
I encourage you and your partner to try Nutrisystem. I've been on it one week and lost 3 pounds. My goal is to lose 15. The entrees are pretty good actually. I don't care for the cookies and the pretzels are horrible. There is a LOT of food to eat in a day at 1200 calories. I jazz up a pizza with tomatoes, onions, and olives (personal food choices to go with the plan). I am back in the habit of eating breakfast now. The plan encourages exercise. In my first week I hit a mile on the treadmill at 2.7 mph. Good for me! I'll probably stay with Nutrisystem for a second full month. You will have to shop for some foods. I use canned fruits and vegetables. You and hubby can split that can of green beans. No waste! The meals are also portable which sounds imperative with your schedules. Good luck.

Reply
Janet

I tried Nutrisystem and really did not care for the food. Additionally, it was more expensive than it sounds because all of your fruits, vegetables and dairy items need to purchased in addition to the daily price of the included items. I found I was doing a lot of food preparation and also wasting a lot of food I was buying on the side. For instance, for a hamburger, they send you the handburger patty, you need to buy the buns and everything else that goes with that meal. By the time you eat another hamburger, you will need fresh buns. I am going to try one of the plans that includes EVERYTHING.... the cost will be about the same in the end and I don't need to go to the grocery store to be lured by non-diet products.

Reply
Kailash

Do your own pre-packaged food plan: Cook a bunch of food on a Sunday (or whenever you have time), put it into storage containers and re-heat it throughout the week. Ideas: a whole chicken, pot roast, skillet filled with burgers or steaks, steamer filled with asparagus, brocolli, carrots, etc. Just make a bunch of food and partition it into storage containers. Take those with you throughout the week. It should only take about 3 hours or so to do this, and will save a lot of time during the week. And you'll always have a healthy meal on hand.

Reply
Kirk VandenBerghe

There's a place--at least in the commercial market--for packaged foods. Still, my bottom line is how real (vs. processed-manufactured), fresh, and nutrient-filled the food is. Is it actual food or simulated food? I've only looked at Nutrisystem, and it's processed junk food in my view.

Reply
Eeyoreem

I've been looking into one of the delivered plans because while I can cook and actually do it well I really hate doing it. I find most of the time I'm too lazy in the kitchen to cook a healthy meal and I would rather just heat up a frozen pizza because its less work for me. I work odd hours and by the time I get home I just want to throw something in the microwave/oven and then eat it when the timer goes off. I try to keep a stack of frozen dinners such as south beach or healthy choice in the freezer for those times when I just can't get the motivation to cook. Does anyone have any suggestions as to one of these "convience diets" might be a better one? I'm on a limited budget too.

Reply
Bella

I would NOT reccomened Zone Chefs now called Chefs Diet. Delivery is not at all reliable, customer service is impossilbe to reach and their sales dept is VERY agressive. When I (again) did not receive an entire weekends worth of meals (of course did not discover until Sat AM) I couldn't get a hold of anyone in their office. I DID however get multiple sales calls on my cell phone all weekend asking me to renew. They started calling at 8am both Saturday and Sunday hounding me to renew on the very weekend they "forgot" to deliver the much counted on meals. The food may be tasty, but everything else about this company is awful. STAY AWAY!

Reply
rufus

in terms of pushy sales people - just be glad they didn't break your legs - see NYP article:

A CELEBRITY-endorsed diet service used by thousands of New Yorkers was really a cover operation to hide fat profits made through organized crime, sources told the Daily News yesterday. Some of the owners of Zone Chefs - which counts Kevin Costner and Liza Minnelli among its famous customers - were involved in a stock market scam controlled by the Colombo crime family, according to court documents. Ties between the Madison Ave. firm and the mob were revealed Thursday when cops swooped in on an operation to sell penny stocks at inflated prices. Among the 10 suspects arrested was Zone Chefs' president, Arthur Gunning, who allegedly beat a broker to keep him in line. Legal papers and sources close to the investigation say other suspects in the stock scam also had links to Zone Chefs, including ultraviolent Colombo soldier Craig Marino, who has "F--- the Police" tattooed across his chest. Federal prosecutors say Marino was caught on a wiretap admitting an ownership stake in the business, which delivers meals to dieters. Robert Podlog, identified by authorities as being linked to both the Colombo family and Russian organized crime, also has a stake, legal papers say. "[A witness] has advised that Podlog and Craig Marino are silent owners of the business," the documents state. The arrests followed a probe into the "pump and dump" stock scam, which used boiler-room brokerage firms secretly controlled by the Colombo family and soaked investors for $20 million, authorities said. Recalcitrant brokers were kept in line with violence, prosecutors charge. In one incident, Gunning hit a stockbroker who threatened to leave the operation with a golf club while Podlog stabbed the man in the head, prosecutors said. Calls to Zone Chefs' attorney were not returned. Representatives for many of the celebrities who provided testimonials on the company's Web site declined to comment. anichols@nydailynews.com

Reply
Jim F.

The article you've referenced (link) is actually 3 years old... so presumably the mob is not still in control.

Reply
Tara

I have been on chefs diet for a week and they are horrible. The food is very bland and often the fruits are old and their lettuce wilted. they have horrible customer services. Stay far away!!!!

Reply
shirley

I AGREE Chefs Diet is Horrible. and buyer beware. when you cancel they claim to need nearly a week notice and also if you cancel your daily rate goes up. The food is bland and freezer burnt. customer service is non existent. when you contact them they have you call another line and then that person asks if someone else can call you! bottom line....don't make the same mistake we did!

Reply
Lory

I was very skeptical about ordering from Chefs Diet because of the bad reviews here. I just wanted to let everyone know that I ordered and LOVED it. I'm sorry so many ppl had bad experiences, but wanted to say that I used it for six weeks in October and November, and I have only good things to say. Sometimes the food was not to my tastes, but this was maybe one meal a week. And even then, I was able to eat it. The other meals ranged from pretty good to excellent, IMO. I loved the muffins, the cupcakes, the pancakes, and the salads. I also really (really) liked the beef and lamb meals. Soo good! I also ate out occassionally and still lost weight. I moved from NY to DC and now wish the fresh delivery was available here. (I was located in Park Slope Brooklyn and had very reliable delivery (at 9pm every night) and fresh foods.)

Reply
Mari

I have been on (about 3 years ago) NutriSystem and while a very few meals were tolerable I couldn't handle that shelf-stable bland food. I'm on the Chef's Diet Solutions frozen lunch and dinners ($10.99 per day) and I have not had one single meal that I didn't like. In fact they are ALL delicious! I just had the Zesty Tortilla-Crusted Tilapia Fillet with Fiesta Corn, Black Bean & Red Bell Pepper Toss for lunch and it was SUPERB! These are super gourmet meals and I'd never go back to NutriSystem. I could live on these meals for the rest of my life and that's no exaggeration!

Reply
Mari

Oh by the way, I've lost 8 lbs in a week and a half. I love it because I don't even have to worry about what I'm going to eat.

Reply


More comments: 1 2 3

Add Your Comment

Required
Required (never displayed)

Be nice. There's already enough mean people in the world.


Created / Updated: February 7, 2012

WHAT IS DIET BLOG?

We take the best of diet news and advice - and combine it with real-world application and opinion.

Find out who we are and don't hesitate to contact us, we'd love to hear from you.

"We're fatter than ever while popular media is saturated with skinny. How did it get to be so complicated?"

Privacy Policy | Sponsor Policy & Disclosure | Terms of Use | Medical Disclaimer ©2003-2011 Diet-Blog v2.0 - All Rights Reserved.