You are in: Home / Diet Reviews / No Flour, No Sugar Diet: Is It That Simple?

No Flour, No Sugar Diet: Is It That Simple?

gotts-no-flour-no-sugar-diet.jpgThe No Flour, No Sugar Diet is written by Dr. Peter Gott - a popular health columnist and medical practitioner.

Subtitled "The Simplest Way to Lose Weight", the book is based on a simple premise....

Eliminate all foods that are flour-based or contain added sugars.

Sounds easy, right?

The book has been popular for many years now, perhaps indicative of our desire for a simple solution.

The trouble is, a truly simple solution wouldn't fill a book, and to fill up a book, simple can become convoluted.

No Flour, No Sugar Diet Highlights

Eliminating flour and sugar effectively reduces the amount of "empty" calories from your diet. Many of these foods (based on refined carbohydrates) are also high in fat (pizza, donuts, etc).

The premise is a good one. Despite all the contrary dietary advice of recent years - there does seem to be a growing consensus about refined carbohydrates: We eat too much of them and they provide us with little nutritive value - not to mention the issue of glycemic response.

No Flour, No Sugar addresses the finer points of reading food labels (and determining what is a flour or sugar).

The book also gives a nod to the value of exercise - suggesting half an hour a day. In keeping with simplicity Dr Gott doesn't bother with complex phases or waves - from Day 1 you "simply" eliminate flours and sugars.

Inconsistencies

In Dr. Gott's introduction he mentions that "no one wants to be bothered with counting calories" and "you don't want to memorize daunting lists of food".

However as you progress through the book, you do indeed come across daunting lists of food, and a detailed chart of daily calorie requirements.

Like many diet authors, Gott takes great pains to deride "fad diets", and in particular low-carb diets. What is ironic here, is that by reducing refined carbs (i.e. flour and sugar) from your diet - you are, by default, embarking on a form of a low or reduced carb diet.

This is unless you continue (or begin) to eat lots of rice or potatoes (which are perfectly acceptable in this diet).

Is It Practical?

gotts-no_flour_no_sugar_cookbook.jpgSimple in concept may not necessarily be simple in execution. The No Flour, No Sugar Diet has 80 pages (almost half the book) devoted to meal plans and recipes.

Call me cynical, but if the diet is as simple as dropping flour and sugar, then why do we need loads of recipes?

For a person who lives on pizza, bread rolls, and donuts - suddenly eating Spiced Edamame and Vietnamese Shrimp Wraps (p. 101) may present something of a challenge.

Luckily, Gott also published a recipe collection to accompany his diet for those that struggle without bread and pasta.

Could it Work?

If the average person removed flour and sugar-based foods from their diet they would probably experience weight loss. These kind of foods make a large part of our modern diet, and, in my opinion, are at the root of many health issues.

Gott has the right premise, but fails to address behavioural issues - or the reason why we eat the way we do. Those who are already familiar with the basic mechanics of healthy weight loss will find nothing new here.

Dr. Gott's No Flour, No Sugar Diet by Peter H Gott. 186 pages, available at Amazon.

Read More

457 Comments

weight loss

Well, it has some good points about eliminating calories but serious how well can someone stick to this diet. I myself would find it impossible and cheating on a regular basics. I don't know it just amazes me some of the diets that come out.

Reply
Sebastian

Well, I've never read this book, but I instinctively embarked on this diet. I can tell you this, if you can make it through the first week to week and a half, you don't crave wheat flour or sugar.

You won't cheat, because the craving for wheat and sugar is like an addiction. A sugar addiction. When you kick the sugar addiction, you'll feel alot better.

It's not about losing weight fast, health care practitioners recommend not losing more than 2 pounds a week anyway. So you have to be patient. And do some sports a couple of days a week.

It's nearly impossible in modern "convenience" shopping to cut out all sugars or wheat flour from our diets. You'll find wheat in almost all packaged foods.

Choosing to eat a meat dish or other high protein soy product with a large dish of steamed vegetables mixed with nuts likes cashews or cranberries for vitamin c, with no grains, I can tell you first hand is very filling for dinner. It's more about breaking habits or what we believe is "normal to eat for dinner." I don't know about you all, but I remember being raised in school to always eat the from the 4 major food groups. Bread was nearly considered its own food group. If you can get out your head and reprogram your mind to eat differently, it works and feels way more stable energy-wise, not only calorie-wise.

Reply
Kathleen

I just started this diet last week but have not as yet bought Gott's book. Common sense dictated this really is how I should be eating. I enjoyed reading your opinion.

Reply
NeNe

I think you are spot on! I have been eating a diet absent of flour/suagr for a little over a week and remarkably, I feel lighter mentally and physically. The food I eat is "live" food. I believe this is they way to nourish your body. Thanks for your comment.

Reply
peggy

I have been doing this diet for three months now and have lost 63 pounds and 4 pants sizes the first week is the hardest but after the third week i no longer craved any of the foods i could not have if you need to lose weight this i a great way you will start to look beter and feel beter rite away if you have any questions or just need a word of advice or encuragement you can email me @ peggymorelock@hotmail.com

Reply
MAGGIE

what type of foods do you eat then if you dont mind me askinb

Reply
vickie winwin

no sugar no flour

Reply
vickie winwin

no sugar no flour

Reply
Marilyn

I do so much better on a sugar/flour free diet:
Proteins, fruits, veggies, whole grains (oatbran,oatmeal,brown rice)limited fats.
Proteins: plain yogurt (greek is awesome)
cheese, eggs,chicken,fish,beef,tofu
All fruits (I don't eat any dried fruits..too sweet
All veggies
Oil: 2-3 tabls.of oil,butter or dressing
grains:oatbran, oatmeal,brown rice
There is a alot of wonderful menu plans with the above.

Reply
Victoria

Is plain yogurt - Greek style - NOT low fat ok to eat on this diet? What about Bear Naked Granola?

Reply
Frank

Yogurt is good. As long as there are no added sugars. I've used Chobani's Plain. And like he says in the book, sugars can be disguised so do your research if you see an ingredient you're not familiar with.

I've been on this diet for a year now. Started as a gluten-free diet, then evolved into the no sugar no wheat diet. I'm 35, my cholesterol is 121, and by body fat is at 8%.

Reply
Lisa

How's the dieting been going so far? I've been doing low carb for the past month but find myself really craving certain fruits. Do you have to watch your intake of eggs and potatoes while on this diet?

Reply
Richard Young

On a no sugar diet can you use fruit juice instead?
Thank you very much

Reply
heather

Hello. I have just checked out The No Sugar, No Flour Book from the library. I was wondering if there were any other recipes that are good to stick to this diet? I am not actually on the program, but I plan to start very soon. It just does not seem like there is alot of recipes that suit my taste. Please let me know if there are any suggestions. Thank you.
Heather

Reply
janet t

I have been on this food plan for three years because I was obsessed with thoughts of flour and sugar and fats. It is not easy because I really am addicted to f/s/and fats. But I can say that the cravings are not as awful as they used to be. For breakfast I eat oatbran, banana and milk. Lunch I have plain protein, salad, cooked veg., grain, oil, yougart. supper is the same except I have fruit instead of yougart. I have to wgt and meas everthing so there is some portion control. It is not easy but I do it anyway.

Reply
erin

FYI, there is sugar in milk. Plain unsweetened almond milk is a good alternative though!

Reply
liz

The sugar in milk is natural, just like in fruit and fruit juice which is allowed in this diet.

Reply
Lisa Dillard

Heather, I have been on this diet for about three months and have lost 25 lbs. I have not exercised at all and I drink beer. I would probably lose more if I would change those things some. I have a good recipe for corn bread, chicken enchiladas, taco stew and some others. I have found a pasta (Heartland) that is 100% whole wheat or whole grain--No Flour and Prego Marinara Sauce has no sugar. Blue Bell has no sugar added ice cream that is good. The only bread I have found is the Ezekiel bread which you have to get at the health food store. Found some dressings by Walden Farms at the health food store too.

Reply
Kim

Hi Lisa,
My husband and I are just starting on this diet. I appreciate reading your findings such as Heartland whole wheat pasta and Blue Bell ice cream - the ice cream habit is going to be hard to break!
Would you be willing to share some of your recipes that you mentioned? I've got Dr Gott's cookbook but rather try some things that are already "tried and true".
Thanks so much and have a happy, healthy 2010!!
Kim

Reply
Linda

I am planing on starting the diet in the next couple days. Need to make sure i understand it first. Planning on buying the book tomorrow. Can you tell me if you are able to eat fruit or is it limited because of the natural sugar.

Thanks
Linda

Reply
lnda

where can I get the recipes you talked about- I started diet a week ago and lov it

Reply
Debbie Eubanks

Would you care to share your recipes? Thanks,Debbie

Reply
debbie

Peggy,just wanted you to know i sent email to you ..Have been on diet 1 week, very commited, no cheating at all and did not lose a pound..help..Debbie

Reply
Pat

Hi, I have been no flour no sugar for 4 weeks and have not lost weight (nor found any:) but my clothes are becoming comfortable again. Do you have any advice?

Reply
Rae

If your clothes are fitting more comfortably then you are losing inches! It's not always the number you see on the scale that maters. Many times people get discouraged on diets because of the scale. Try taking your measurments and comparing those over time as well as your weight. Seeing those positive results can really help keep you motivated!

Reply
Anita

I am having this same experience. Did you ever lose any weight?

Reply
Lori

Hi

My name is Lori and I've thought about trying this but not sure what types of food I'll be able to eat.Could you give me some tips?

Reply
Kim

It would be great to have an expert so that I can ask questions. I just got the book from the library, but it doesn't say anything about maltodextrin. Do you know if it is OK?

Reply
ValGal

I have only been on this diet for less than a week but would love to know if either pizza (home made) or any pasta is in this diet. I have eaten no flour except what is in the Ezekiel bread. This has been quite an experience since I have just started reading the labels and found that sugar is in EVERYTHING! Now trying to find something without flour is another task.

Reply
Sarah

i have been doing this for a few days now and i find it actually kind of easy. instead of no flour i have been doing no white flour because white flour is the worst for you. instead you can substitute whole grains and wheats. there are wheat and whole grain pastas, breads, bagels, English muffins, etc. and there are healthy spreads such as nutella you can spread on your bagel or English muffin. also, i have never really liked salads, but i made a vegetable salad with celery, red green banana and yellow pepper, broccoli, cauliflower and carrot pieces. you can find low-fat dressings such as this low fat caeser i found that also has only one carb! you can make fruit salads, etc. just be creative and test with healthy things around the house or go shopping. i have done this before and i lost a few pounds in a month and i am normal weight to begin with. my stomach also flattened out.

Reply
cyuuu

Peggy, I've read your other post before and you said that we can eat rice noodles. Is that really okay even though its made out of rice flour?

i would love to email you if I have any further questions or when I need some support/encouragement if that's okay.

you can email me msclarayu@hotmail.com

Reply
Anelea

do you know of any bread or breakfast cereal with no flour, no sugar?? and are there any pasta that will work on this diet

Reply
Janice

you can eat shredded wheat cereal.

Reply
Jay

try Alpen cereal... I believe Weetabix produces them - whole grain, preservative free and sugar free. Or make your own muesli!

Reply
michelle

Hi Peggy....I think it's so wonderful that you have done so well. I think I am truly addicted to sugar and white flour. I was told this many years ago by a nutritionist and thought she was crazy. But I have steadily gained weight over the years and I can't seem to control it. Can you write back to me and give me some more words of wisdom? I need to make a change now. I feel like I am drowning.

Reply
Cindy

Can you give me a sample menu of your week.
Thanks,
Cindy

Reply
Lisa

I did this diet for about 5 months (about a year ago)and lost 50 pounds and worked with a trainer 2x/wk - felt great looked even better - THEN i started eating a few things here and there NOT recommended (sugar, flour) and now in this year, I have gained back 30 pounds. Conclusion for me - as with any "diet" or food plan change or whatever you want to call it, if I go back to the old way I WILL gain it back. If I don't address the reason why I eat the sugar - then I will probably go back to the old me over and over again. I am in week one once again - if I weren't so HUNGRY i'd be feeling pretty darn good - but i AM hungry!!

Reply
Me

If you can't control your eating at all don't bother reading anything about dieting or healthy eating.

Reply
karin

Then maybe you really weren't addicted to carbs or sugar. After 1 1/2 weeks cutting these down as low as possible in modern life, I'm controlling it for the first time in my life. It's a miracle for addicts like me.

Reply
jennifer

My aunt has been on this diet since September of 2008 and has lost 40 lbs. She has stuck to it everyday. My husband and I just started it in March of 2009. He has already lost 20 lbs and I myself have lost 12lbs. It is honestly a very hard diet to stick too and I think that if you are committed to it and want to lose the weight then you will do your best. My advise to anyone about this diet is, "If you want to lose weight then you will not cheat and you will notice a difference right away." Good Luck

Reply
zorro

Actually, I follow this diet. I also do not eat potatoes or rice. I've followed this diet for almost 2 years. It can be done. It is a challenge.

I've never felt healthier. Do I get cravings(?)--yes! But, I tell myself--humans were not designed to eat high-glycemic foods.

When I dine out, I get double vegetables and eat no bread. Again, it can be done. I've done it and I am no longer pre-diabetic, or overweight. My lab work is the best the doctor has ever seen.

Again, it is excellent advice and it can be done.

Reply
DD

If you seriously want to lose weight this is the easiest best way to do it! I've been trying to lose my 40lb pregnancy weight gain for 6 years. I've never been able to "stick with it" for more than 2 weeks. I've been focusing on staying away from sugar and flour and processed foods and have steadily lost 2lbs a week for a month now. This is something I can adapt for life bec. I "allow" myself a "slip" up once a week or so. Like a home made muffin or some frozen yogurt. I eat my meals until I'm really full, too. So I'm not hungry all the time. No counting calories!
Sample meals for a day
B)Oatmeal made with milk sprinkle of cinnamon and a little brown sugar and coffee with a small spoon of sugar (see a little sugar-no problem)
L)broiled chicken with salad or sweet potato
snacks of almonds and a banana (as much snack as you need to keep full)sometimes a string cheese
D)broiled salmon and salad

You can do this! Good Luck!

Reply
maddy

well it is a problem if your following a no sugar diet!

try agave nector, you can find it health stores or supermarkets or online if you have trouble finding it elsewhere.

its a natural sweetener, you can mix it into hot drinks pour it on porridge or use it in baking

it really does taste just like sugar in drinks, and honey on porridge.

Reply
Ryan

There are many good carb sources out there to choose from. Yams and sweet potatoes taste great. I especially love baked yams with a little salt. Also, there are beans like navy and pinto. Finally you have whole grains like brown-rice, steel-cut oatmeal, cracked wheat, and so on.

One thing I find about sweets is that the more you eat them, the more you crave them. I've been avoiding sugars for quite a while, and now it's quite difficult for me to actually eat them now. I have to "brace myself" for it.

Bread is slightly harder. However, the occasional whole-grain bread isn't all that bad for you.

Reply
iFitandHealthy

I like it. The concept is simple. The execution is a completely different matter, but usually, a scheduled “cheat” day takes care of the cravings.

If a person enjoys a little too much pizza, bread rolls, and donuts, I would recommend eating these foods after a workout. Well, let me rephrase that. Those that cannot live without these foods could minimize the impact if they eat them after a workout.

They can do even better if they add some lean protein. Although, skinless chicken breast with donuts could prove a little challenging to swallow.

Reply
Robyn

Since this seems to be the number one fad today, I am invitong everyone to try me new diet. It is called "Turn off the T.V., Put down that dougnut and get up and move your butt."

If you want to get published today don't write something that may help inmprove our minds, write a dieting book. With a new one coming out every second week who knows what they will have us try yet. But one thing is for sure, it will be farther and farther from common sense.

Reply
The Shrinking Knitter

I attended Overeaters Anonymous meetings many years ago, and the mantra at that time was "no sugar, no white flour, no red meat."

I followed that plan, but until I started a regular exercise program of aerobic conditioning and weight training, I didn't lose weight.

I still avoid sugar and white flour, for the most part, but I do eat some of both on occasion. I've lost 43 pounds so far this year, but I have to say I think it's the exercise that deserves the credit.

Reply
Susan

S.K.

I went to OA yearssss ago, now do a similar food plan(Sommer Sizing) I always felt, as I weighed and measured my food, that I was cheating-now I just eat my food types seperatley, and at different times. At OA I lost about 50lbs.- Now this last 3years on Suzanne,s no carb or sugar- just about one hundred lbs. Oh, and I didn't exersice and I am over 50.

Reply
Sandy

I've never read this book, but I've been following the advice of no flour, no "added" sugar since April 4, 2005, and I've lost 78 pounds. It's simple advice and it works! I've not been tempted to cheat, because the cravings just go away. The diet, though, is just a low carb diet. You can name it Adkins, South Beach, Sugar Busters...but it's basically the same. You can't really say NO sugar, because there's natural sugar in fruit such as strawberries, but I don't eat any processed sugar.

Reply
nmmamacita0309

I make alot of mexican food and the way I have always made my chile it calls for flour, that thickens up the sauce. What could I use in place? Is there a Diet Menu u can use like a 7-Day menu plann? What is a list of white foods. Can I find it online? Thanks you.

Reply
Cynthia

You could use corn starch

Reply
Diet Blog

Robyn: "Turn off the T.V., Put down that doughnut and get up and move your butt."... I think I saw that book in the bookshop the other day ;-)

Seriously, I think you'll find that many people who manage their weight avoid lots of baked products and sweet stuff. Most of those foods are truly "nutritionally deprived".

Reply
del

robyn--i think you might be retarded or just dumb

Reply
robyn

flamer

Reply
heather

LOL!!!

Reply
Ryan

Actually, with all the bad things being said about refined sugar, you may be shocked to find out that it can be used to your advantage. After a strenuous workout, a drink containing fast-acting proteins like whey and fast-acting sugar will hasten your recovery. This has been highly researched. It's important to note that you're least likely to store calories as fat immediately after a workout. Your muscles and liver soak it all up.

Reply
RedPanda

Like others here, I've been following the "no flour, no sugar" (except for post-workout) diet for some time and it works! It's also cured my cravings for "bad" carbs. Although the diet sounds sensible, people will try it, give up because it's "too hard" to follow, then look around for the next quick fix.

Sigh... we really need only one diet book - "Turn off the T.V., Put down that doughnut and get up and move your butt." But somehow, I don't think it will be a best-seller!

Reply
Ryan

That diet book does exist, but it goes by the name "Burn the Fat, Feed the Muscle". Surprisingly, it was ranked as the #1 diet e-book and #1 fitness e-book on the Internet. It works, and it promotes permanent weight loss. It's all about eating healthy, natural foods, doing cardio, and lifting weights for life, or as long as you'd like to be thin.

One thing it does do that's unusual is address the dreaded weight loss plateau. Most people act like it doesn't exist. They won't sell as well if they tell you your weight loss could suddenly halt, seemingly for no reason. This book gives you many ways to get around it.

The book also has the little tricks that bodybuilders have found over the years that will accelerate your fat loss or bust any plateau.

The only problem I have with it is the author's stance on saturated fat, but nothing's perfect.

Reply
Diet Blog

Ryan, BFFM is a great book (one of my favorites), and Tom was always quite helpful (although I think far too busy these days to respond).

Please keep comments related to the current post (No flour no sugar diet).

Reply
Robyn

I was reading my post and I have got to quit typing in the dark. That was awful, I feel so ashamed :(

Regardless I think that the general idea behind these books are good. Cutting back on sugar and flour, very good ideas. And I will be the first to admit that the more and more sugar that you cut from your diet the more you taste it in the food that you eat and what you drink. But then again maybe that is the advice that we need to hear. I don't really know. But I do know that most of these books and the supposed science that feeds them are very contradictory.

Don't eat Carbs, Wait, okay now eat them. Coffee is bad for you, this week. But next week we'll find a possible benefit to drinking it. This goes on and on. Makes you almost wonder how trustworthy these studies are. And thank you Jim, it is such a nice thing to see that you read and post responses on these topics. :)

Reply
Diet Blog

Robyn: People's comments are the best part. With 80 comments across the site in the last 24 hours it's difficult to get to them all.

Anyways, I agree that the premise of this book is good. But in all honesty -- in so many books I see the same info peddled out again and again. And soooo many assumptions are made without source or reference. I often wonder if some of the authors actually use Ghost Writers.

Reply
Robyn

See and that is where I find there is an issue. Anyone can spout out ideas and thoughts but were is the proof. And this isn't about saying that every diet that comes along is a sham and therefore justifying the problem that is facing us about being unhealthy. But there is just too much of it. It isn't about our health anymore it is about making money and there lies the bigger issue. When all of us finally shape up and stop listening to the media, close our mouths and get healthy they will simply find something else to pick our bones about. You stated in an earlier post that the best plan of action is to wade through all of the adivce and just pick out the parts that make sense to each individual and that is so unbelievably true. Heck you could even do it with the titles alone.

Today I will go to the SOUTH BEACH, I will choose to eliminate all FLOUR and SUGAR from my DIET and perhaps chose a healthy dinner and drink some CALIFORNA WINE. Tomorrow I will get up and enjoy my bowl of low-fat,watered down, skim milk, on a single size serving of SPECIAL K ceral. As I sit there eating my cardboard like substance I will think about that crazy Dr, What was his name? Oh right ATKINS who thinks eating four or five servings of meat is great but veggies will get you off track. Then go back to my orginal thought, which was the eternal question of why FRENCH WOMEN NEVER GET FAT.

Que Sera, Sera!!!!!

Reply
Julie

Oprah did a show on that once. A french woman came in and everything. She said that they never ate until they were full. Also, she said that if they were to have something really fattening at night like a donut or a croissant then they would balance it so that the next morning they would have a yogurt instead of eggs or something.

Reply
Gina

If you are eliminating all flour and sugar you shouldn't be eating Special K. Unsweetened shredded wheat and oatmeal are examples of acceptable cereals on the no flour no sugar eating plan. Special K has both flour and sugar. You need to read labels a lot to follow the eating plan.

Reply
Jennifer

Oh please.. French Women do get fat! They smoke like chimney's and it should be ''Parisians never get fat!'' Because they walk every where. I lived in Paris as a Scottish American for 5 years and trust me they smoke, drink and hardly eat at all..

The culture in Paris is fashion obsessed and this airy fairy ,refined society you think it is only exist superficially.

Yes, it is lovely and yes French people are charming and thoughtful but many,many of them are very introspective and surly. They live marginally longer than the average American (even with socialized medicine) and their ''ideal'' lifestyle.

What you have to understand as well, is that if you are a Caucasian and live in the US,you usually will either have Gaelic/Anglo-Saxon or Germanic Genes.

Which means by default you will be larger framed with more muscle mass. Is it an excuse to be obese.. No!

This is all just a thought and an observation. Once again, Americans do not delude yourself that Euros are much , thinner or happier than you because they are not!

Reply
Diet Blog

While you are lying on the South Beach, make sure you earn lots of money -- then you can tell us How the Rich Get Thin... ;-)

Reply


More comments: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19

Add Your Comment

Required
Required (never displayed)

Be nice. There's already enough mean people in the world.


Created / Updated: December 8, 2011

WHAT IS DIET BLOG?

We take the best of diet news and advice - and combine it with real-world application and opinion.

Find out who we are and don't hesitate to contact us, we'd love to hear from you.

"We're fatter than ever while popular media is saturated with skinny. How did it get to be so complicated?"

Privacy Policy | Sponsor Policy & Disclosure | Terms of Use | Medical Disclaimer ©2003-2011 Diet-Blog v2.0 - All Rights Reserved.